Floor Vote for

Bill Number:	0248
Date:	Friday, April 24, 2015
Reading #:	3
Barcode #:	NA
Sequence:	356
In the Chair:	Hudson
Floor Actions:	Passage

Y Adkins
Y Ahern
Y Albritton
Y Antone
Y Artiles
Y Avila
Y Baxley
Y Berman
- Beshears
Y Bileca
Y Boyd
Y Bracy
Y Brodeur
Y Broxson
Y Burgess
Y Burton
Y Caldwell
Y Campbell
Y Clarke-Reed
Y Combee
Y Corcoran
Y Cortes, B.
Y Cortes, J.
Y Costello
Y Crisafulli
Y Cruz
Y Cummings
Y Diaz, J.
Y Diaz, M.
Y Drake
Y DuBose
Y Dudley
Y Eagle
Y Edwards-Walpole
Y Eisnaugle
Y Fant
Y Fitzenhagen
Y Fresen
Y Fullwood
Y Gaetz
Y Geller
Y Gonzalez
Y Goodson
Y Grant, J.
- Hager
Y Harrell
Y Harrison
Y Hill
Y Hudson
Y Ingoglia
Y Ingram
- Jacobs
Y Jenne
Y Jones
Y Jones, M.
Y Kerner
Y La Rosa
Y Latvala
Y Lee
Y Magar
Y Mayfield
Y McBurney
Y McGhee
Y Metz
Y Miller, M.
Y Moraitis
Y Moskowitz
Y Murphy
Y Narain
Y Nuñez
Y Oliva
Y O'Toole
N Pafford
Y Passidomo
Y Perry
Y Peters
Y Pigman
Y Pilon
Y Plakon
Y Plasencia
Y Porter
Y Powell
Y Pritchett
Y Raburn
Y Rader
Y Raschein
Y Raulerson
Y Ray
- Rehwinkel Vasilinda
Y Renner
Y Richardson
Y Roberson, K.
- Rodrigues, R.
N Rodríguez, J.
Y Rogers
Y Rooney
Y Rouson
Y Santiago
Y Slosberg
Y Smith
Y Spano
Y Sprowls
Y Stafford
Y Stark
Y Steube
Y Stevenson
Y Stone
Y Sullivan
Y Taylor
Y Tobia
Y Torres
Y Trujillo
Y Trumbull
- Van Zant
Y Watson, B.
Y Watson, C.
Y Williams, A.
Y Wood
Y Workman
Y Young

Total Yeas: 112

Total Nays: 2

Total Abstained: 0

Total Missed: 6

Total Votes: 114

Vote After Roll Call:

Yeas

Beshears

04/27/2015 01:21:41 PM
Hager

04/24/2015 04:03:13 PM
Jacobs

04/24/2015 04:00:17 PM
Rehwinkel Vasilinda

04/29/2015 06:38:52 PM
Rodrigues, R.

04/28/2015 12:23:54 PM

Explanations of Vote:

Pafford -

When it comes to public records exemptions and laws relating to privacy and public safety, it is important to write our laws very carefully since drafting errors can have far-reaching negative consequences. CS for CS for CS for SB 248 contains such drafting errors including the following: lines 29, 34 & 58 allow the parent of an ADULT the ability to obtain a recording as of right; lines 47-50 allow law enforcement agencies very broad and ill-defined discretion on how and when to voluntarily disclose recordings that would otherwise be protected; lines 39-46 allow for too much ambiguity in where and when recorded material may be withheld as confidential and exempt to provide for fair, judicious and consistent application; lines 55-57 & 59-61 do not provide sufficient instruction to law enforcement on the release of a recording; and other drafting problems.
Rodríguez, J. -

When it comes to public records exemptions and laws relating to privacy and public safety, it is important to write our laws very carefully since drafting errors can have far-reaching negative consequences. CS for CS for CS for SB 248 contains such drafting errors including the following: lines 29, 34 & 58 allow the parent of an ADULT the ability to obtain a recording as of right; lines 47-50 allow law enforcement agencies very broad and ill-defined discretion on how and when to voluntarily disclose recordings that would otherwise be protected; lines 39-46 allow for too much ambiguity in where and when recorded material may be withheld as confidential and exempt to provide for fair, judicious and consistent application; lines 55-57 & 59-61 do not provide sufficient instruction to law enforcement on the release of a recording; and other drafting problems.