Floor Vote for

Bill Number: 0102
Date: Friday, March 24, 2023
Reading #: 3
Barcode #: NA
Sequence: 44
In the Chair: Renner
Floor Actions: Passage

  • Y Abbott
  • Y Altman
  • Y Alvarez
  • Y Amesty
  • Y Anderson
  • Y Andrade
  • Y Antone
  • Y Arrington
  • Y Baker
  • Y Bankson
  • Y Barnaby
  • Y Bartleman
  • Y Basabe
  • Y Bell
  • N Beltran
  • Y Benjamin
  • Y Berfield
  • Y Black
  • Y Borrero
  • Y Botana
  • Y Brackett
  • Y Bracy Davis
  • Y Brannan
  • Y Buchanan
  • Y Busatta Cabrera
  • Y Campbell
  • Y Canady
  • Y Caruso
  • Y Casello
  • Y Cassel
  • - Chambliss
  • - Chaney
  • Y Clemons
  • Y Cross
  • Y Daley
  • Y Daniels
  • Y Driskell
  • Y Duggan
  • Y Dunkley
  • Y Edmonds
  • N Eskamani
  • Y Esposito
  • Y Fabricio
  • Y Fernandez-Barquin
  • Y Fine
  • Y Franklin
  • N Gantt
  • Y Garcia
  • Y Garrison
  • Y Giallombardo
  • Y Gonzalez Pittman
  • Y Gossett-Seidman
  • - Gottlieb
  • Y Grant
  • Y Gregory
  • Y Griffitts
  • N Harris
  • Y Hart
  • Y Hawkins
  • Y Hinson
  • Y Holcomb
  • Y Hunschofsky
  • Y Jacques
  • Y Joseph
  • Y Killebrew
  • Y Koster
  • Y LaMarca
  • Y Leek
  • Y López, J.
  • - Lopez, V.
  • Y Maggard
  • Y Maney
  • - Massullo
  • Y McClain
  • Y McClure
  • Y McFarland
  • - Melo
  • Y Michael
  • Y Mooney
  • N Nixon
  • Y Overdorf
  • Y Payne
  • Y Perez
  • - Persons-Mulicka
  • Y Plakon
  • Y Plasencia
  • Y Porras
  • N Rayner
  • Y Renner
  • Y Rizo
  • Y Roach
  • Y Robinson, F.
  • Y Robinson, W.
  • Y Rommel
  • - Roth
  • Y Rudman
  • Y Salzman
  • Y Shoaf
  • - Silvers
  • - Sirois
  • Y Skidmore
  • Y Smith
  • Y Snyder
  • Y Stark
  • Y Steele
  • Y Stevenson
  • Y Tant
  • Y Temple
  • Y Tomkow
  • Y Trabulsy
  • Y Tramont
  • Y Truenow
  • Y Tuck
  • Y Valdés
  • Y Waldron
  • Y Williams
  • Y Woodson
  • Y Yarkosky
  • Y Yeager
Total Yeas: 103
Total Nays: 6
Total Abstained: 0
Total Missed: 10
Total Votes: 109

Vote After Roll Call:

Yeas

  • Chambliss
    03/24/2023 02:18:05 PM
  • Lopez, V.
    03/24/2023 12:41:44 PM
  • Massullo
    03/27/2023 04:54:34 PM
  • Melo
    05/04/2023 09:16:51 AM
  • Persons-Mulicka
    03/29/2023 11:05:10 AM
  • Roth
    03/25/2023 09:40:38 AM
  • Silvers
    03/29/2023 03:05:27 PM
  • Sirois
    03/24/2023 02:45:50 PM

Nays

  • Gottlieb
    03/24/2023 01:16:52 PM

Yeas To Nays

  • Joseph
    04/26/2023 04:24:53 PM

Explanations of Vote:

  • Beltran -
    I fully support a ban on rent controls. However, I must object to the fiscal impact of this bill. I represent a suburban district. My constituents live in the suburbs to obtain sufficient housing at an affordable price. My constituents should not pay taxes to subsidize urban areas. This legislation greatly expands a program that was started as a generous benefit to government employees earning modest salaries. However, this legislation creates an entitlement program for middle-class citizens who can afford housing. Government subsidies increase housing prices for everybody, they do not decrease them. Every dollar of subsidy is first collected in taxes. Persons ineligible for this program, or who do not avail themselves of it, will pay higher taxes to fund this program without any corresponding benefit. Administration of this program will consume resources and allow the waste, fraud, and abuse that is inevitable for any government program. Housing should be left to market forces, which are proven to result in the best quality and price without government subsidy. I support other pending legislation, such as HB 1417, which adequately preempts rent controls. Rent controls create inefficiencies in the market, and limit the quality and availability of housing.
  • Eskamani -
    Though I do support many parts of this bill, the pre-emption is a direct slap in the face of my constituents who voted overwhelmingly for a rental stabilization proposal in 2022. Rental rates are too high, and this bill does nothing to provide immediate relief to families in need right now nor does it strengthen tenant rights. It also offers no clear guarantee that dollars allocated will address where the greatest housing needs are.
  • Gottlieb -
    Out due to covid.